EOR vs Subsidiary in India: Choosing the Right India Expansion Strategy

Q1: What are EOR and Subsidiary Models in India? [toc=EOR & Subsidiary Models]

In our experience helping 100+ global companies establish their presence in India, we've observed that understanding the fundamental differences between EOR and subsidiary models is crucial for making informed decisions about market entry strategies.

Employer of Record (EOR) Model

An Employer of Record (EOR) is a third-party organization that takes on the legal and administrative responsibilities of employing staff in a foreign country on behalf of another company. When utilizing an EOR in India:

• The EOR becomes the legal employer of record for your workers in India
• Your company maintains day-to-day management and operational control
• The EOR handles all payroll processing, tax withholding, and compliance with local laws
• Employment contracts are legally between the employee and the EOR
• The EOR manages statutory benefits, social security contributions, and labor law compliance

The EOR model essentially allows foreign companies to hire and manage teams in India without establishing a legal entity in the country. This arrangement creates a clear separation between employment responsibilities (handled by the EOR) and operational management (retained by your company).

Subsidiary Model

A subsidiary, in contrast, is a separate legal entity established in India that is wholly or partially owned by a foreign parent company. When establishing an Indian subsidiary:

• You create a distinct legal entity registered under Indian corporate law
• The most common structures are Private Limited Companies or Limited Liability Partnerships
• Your company has full control over all aspects of operations and employment
• You directly employ all staff members in India
• You assume full responsibility for all legal, tax, and compliance obligations
• You must maintain statutory books, file annual returns, and complete regular audits

The subsidiary model provides complete ownership and control but requires significant investment in understanding and complying with India's complex regulatory framework.

Key Differences at a Glance

Q2: When Should Companies Choose an EOR vs. a Subsidiary in India? [toc=When to choose EOR?]

Based on our research and experience supporting international businesses entering the Indian market, we've identified several key scenarios that typically favor one model over the other.

When to Choose an EOR Model

Market Testing Phase: Companies exploring the Indian market without a long-term commitment benefit from the flexibility of an EOR. This allows you to establish a presence without significant upfront investment.

Small Team Requirements: If you plan to hire just a few employees in India (typically fewer than 10-15), the operational overhead of maintaining a subsidiary often outweighs the benefits.

Urgent Hiring Needs: When you need to onboard Indian talent quickly, an EOR enables you to start hiring within days rather than waiting months for entity setup.

Compliance Risk Mitigation: India's regulatory landscape is complex and constantly evolving. Companies without dedicated legal expertise in Indian employment law can transfer this risk to an EOR partner.

Budget Constraints: For startups and scaling companies with limited resources, the significantly lower setup and operational costs of an EOR model preserve capital for core business activities.

Short-term Projects: For engagements with a defined timeline (under 2-3 years), the EOR model avoids the complications of establishing and later dissolving a legal entity.

When to Choose a Subsidiary Model

Long-term Strategic Presence: Companies planning a substantial, permanent presence in India with 15+ employees typically benefit from establishing a subsidiary after their initial market entry phase.

Regulatory Requirements: Certain industries in India (like banking, insurance, and defense) have restrictions that may require a local entity for full operations.

Full Control Requirements: Organizations needing complete control over employment policies, corporate governance, and intellectual property protection may prefer direct employer status.

Tax Optimization: Companies seeking to fully leverage tax treaties, transfer pricing strategies, and local incentives often require a legal entity structure.

Local Contracting Needs: Businesses that need to enter into significant local contracts, lease office space, or purchase assets directly may require a subsidiary.

Brand Presence: Establishing a subsidiary can enhance market perception, demonstrating a committed local presence that may be advantageous for client relationships and local hiring.

Hybrid Approaches

In our work with global companies, we've seen successful implementations of hybrid approaches:

1. EOR-to-Subsidiary Transition: Starting with an EOR for quick market entry, then transitioning to a subsidiary once operations reach a certain scale
2. Mixed Model: Using an EOR for certain employee categories while maintaining a subsidiary for others
3. Testing-to-Permanence: Utilizing an EOR during a market testing phase before committing to permanent entity establishment

The choice between EOR and subsidiary should align with your company's stage, resources, timeline, and strategic objectives in the Indian market. As we'll explore in subsequent sections, compliance requirements and costs vary significantly between these models, particularly for US-based companies.

Q3: What Additional Compliance Requirements Do US Companies Face When Setting Up a Subsidiary in India? [toc=Additional US Compliance Requirements]

In our experience helping global companies establish a presence in India, we've observed that US companies often underestimate the extensive compliance obligations that come with setting up a subsidiary in India. The Indian regulatory landscape is significantly different from the US system, creating multiple layers of additional compliance requirements.

Types of Compliance Requirements

Indian regulations categorize compliance requirements into three distinct types:

Periodic Compliances
These are requirements that must be fulfilled multiple times throughout the year (quarterly or half-yearly):

• Quarterly GST returns
• TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) quarterly statements
• Foreign remittance reporting
• Board meeting requirements (minimum of four per financial year)
• Employee Provident Fund (EPF) and Employee State Insurance (ESI) monthly filings

Annual Compliances
These must be completed once every fiscal year:

• Annual GST returns
• Annual income tax filings
• Financial statement preparation and audits
• Annual returns with the Registrar of Companies (ROC)
• Annual compliance certificates
• Director's report and financial statement filings
• Annual General Meeting (AGM) requirements13

Event-Based Compliances
These are triggered by specific company actions:

• Changes in company structure or shareholding
• Foreign investment reporting
• Significant transactions with related parties
• Changes in registered office or directors1

Key Regulatory Frameworks for US Companies

When a US company establishes a subsidiary in India, it must navigate multiple regulatory frameworks simultaneously:

Companies Act, 2013

• Mandatory board meetings and record-keeping
• Director residency requirements (at least one director must be resident in India)
• Annual filing requirements with the Registrar of Companies
• Maintenance of statutory registers and records
• Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) obligations for companies meeting certain thresholds35

Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA)

• Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) reporting and compliance
• Annual reporting of foreign investments through Form FC-GPR
• Transfer of shares reporting
• Foreign remittance tracking and documentation
• Overseas direct investment reporting when applicable35

Tax Compliance

• Corporate income tax filings (current rate approximately 25%)
• Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) compliance
• Goods and Services Tax (GST) registration and filings
• Transfer pricing documentation and reporting
• Permanent Account Number (PAN) and Tax Deduction Account Number (TAN) registrations35

Labor Law Compliance

• Employee Provident Fund (EPF) registration and contributions
• Employee State Insurance (ESI) compliance
• Professional Tax registration and payments
• Shop and Establishment Act registration
• Sexual Harassment at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act compliance5

Extra US Reporting Requirements

US parent companies must file several specialized forms:

• Form 5471: Required for US persons with at least 10% ownership in foreign corporations
• Form 926: For reporting transfers of property to foreign corporations
• Form 8832: Allows foreign LLCs to elect their tax classification
• FBAR filings: Required for foreign financial accounts meeting threshold requirements

Failure to file these forms can trigger substantial penalties, including $25,000 fines for non-compliance

US Laws with Extra-territorial Application

US companies must ensure their foreign subsidiaries comply with:

• Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA): Requires robust anti-corruption controls in all global operations
• Export Control Laws: Regulate reexport of US-origin products and technical data
• Anti-boycott Provisions: Can apply with as little as 10% ownership in a foreign entity

Transfer Pricing and Tax Considerations

All transactions between the US parent and Indian subsidiary must follow:

• Arm's-length pricing requirements per IRS Section 482
• Proper documentation for all intercompany transactions, including royalties, service fees, and loans

Do US Taxes Increase with a Foreign Subsidiary?

The answer is complex:

Potential for Higher Taxes:

• Global Intangible Low-Taxed Income (GILTI) provisions enforce a minimum tax on foreign earnings, typically 10.5-13.125%, but sometimes higher
• Pass-through entities (S-corporations, partnerships) face obstacles accessing foreign tax credits
• Recent tax reforms have broadened the US tax base for foreign earnings

Potential for Tax Efficiency:

• Income may be deferred until repatriation (except for GILTI income)
• Foreign tax credits can offset US tax liability on foreign income
• Strategic timing of repatriation can achieve permanent tax savings

The tax impact ultimately depends on your company structure, repatriation strategy, and ability to utilize foreign tax credits. Companies should conduct thorough tax planning with cross-border specialists before establishing a subsidiary in India.

‍

Q4: How Do Costs Compare Between EOR and Subsidiary Models in India? [toc=Costs]

Based on our research and experience supporting over 100 companies entering the Indian market, we've compiled a comprehensive cost comparison between EOR and subsidiary models. Understanding these cost structures is crucial for making informed decisions about your market entry strategy.

Initial Setup Costs

EOR Model Initial Costs:

• Minimal or no setup costs
• Employee onboarding fees (typically one-time charges of $100-200 per employee)
• No legal entity registration expenses
• No minimum capital requirements
• No compliance setup costs

Subsidiary Model Initial Costs:

• Company incorporation fees (₹15,000-25,000)
• Legal and professional services (₹100,000-300,000)
• Minimum capital requirements (dependent on business type)
• Director identification numbers and registrations
• Registered office setup and lease deposits
• Bank account opening and related documentation
• Business licenses and industry-specific permits
• Compliance management systems implementation

The total initial investment for subsidiary setup typically ranges from ₹10-15 lakhs ($12,000-$18,000), excluding working capital requirements4.

Ongoing Operational Costs

EOR Model Ongoing Costs:

• Monthly service fees (typically 8-15% of employee salary)
• Transparent inclusion of all statutory benefits
• No additional compliance management fees
• No separate payroll processing costs
• No audit or filing fees

For example, for an employee with a monthly salary of ₹120,000:

• EOR fee (10%): ₹12,000/month
• Total cost: ₹132,000/month per employee

Subsidiary Model Ongoing Costs:

• Full-time compliance personnel or outsourced compliance services
• Annual audit and filing fees (₹50,000-200,000)
• Monthly payroll processing costs
• Ongoing legal and professional services
• Office maintenance and utility expenses
• Director fees and related expenses
• Banking charges and financial management costs
• Tax filing and advisory services

Annual operational expenses for maintaining a subsidiary typically range from ₹5-10 lakhs ($6,000-$12,000), scaling higher with increased headcount and operational complexity.

Hidden Costs and Considerations

EOR Model Hidden Considerations:

• Potential limitations on intellectual property management
• Less direct control over employment policies
• Service provider quality variations
• Possible constraints on certain business activities

Subsidiary Model Hidden Costs:

• Management time spent on compliance activities
• Risks of penalties for unintentional non-compliance
• Currency fluctuation impacts
• Knowledge gaps in regulatory requirements
• Business continuity risks due to compliance issues
• Time delays in business operations due to regulatory processes

Time-to-Market Costs

A crucial but often overlooked cost factor is the time-to-market impact:

EOR Model:

• Employee onboarding possible within days (typically 1-7 days)
• Immediate ability to issue employment contracts
• No delay in commencing business operations

Subsidiary Model:

• Entity setup timeframe of 2-4 months
• Additional time for obtaining operational permits and registrations
• Delays in hiring and team building activities

For businesses where timing is critical, these delays represent significant opportunity costs that should be factored into the decision-making process.

Cost Comparison Summary

As one search result aptly points out, opting for the seemingly cheaper option of direct hiring without understanding the full compliance landscape could prove to be "penny wise, pound foolish" due to potential long-term costs and legal complications.

‍

Q5: What Tax Implications Should Companies Consider When Choosing Between EOR and Subsidiary Models? [toc=Tax Implications]

When evaluating EOR versus subsidiary models for your India operations, taxation becomes a critical factor that can significantly impact your company's financial performance and compliance obligations. In our experience helping global companies navigate India's complex tax landscape, we've found that each model carries distinct tax implications that must be carefully considered.

Tax Implications of the EOR Model

Simplified Tax Administration
With an EOR model, the EOR provider assumes responsibility for:

• Managing and remitting payroll taxes
• Handling income tax withholdings at appropriate rates
• Ensuring proper social security contributions
• Maintaining compliance with local tax regulations
• Filing all employee-related tax returns

Goods and Services Tax (GST) Considerations

• EOR services typically attract a Goods and Services Tax of 18%
• Depending on the nature of services performed by your Indian team, additional GST requirements may apply
• Your EOR partner handles GST registration and filing requirements

Limited Tax Planning Opportunities

• The EOR model provides less flexibility for international tax planning
• Transfer pricing strategies are generally not applicable
• Limited ability to leverage tax incentives available to registered entities

Permanent Establishment Risks

• Using an EOR doesn't automatically protect against creating a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India
• If your business activities exceed certain thresholds, your company may still have tax reporting obligations in India
• Careful structuring of operations and activities is necessary to manage PE risks

Tax Implications of the Subsidiary Model

Corporate Tax Obligations

• Standard corporate income tax rate of approximately 25.17% (22% plus surcharge and cess)
• Foreign-owned subsidiaries may face higher effective rates up to 40% depending on specific circumstances
• If the parent company is headquartered in India, the rate could potentially be reduced to around 20%

Comprehensive Tax Compliance Requirements

• Quarterly advance tax payments
• Annual income tax returns
• Transfer pricing documentation
• Tax audit requirements
• Director liability for tax compliance

Strategic Tax Planning Opportunities

• Ability to utilize tax treaties between India and your home country
• Potential to access special economic zone benefits and incentives
• Depreciation benefits on capital investments
• Research and development tax incentives
• Strategic transfer pricing arrangements

Comparative Tax Considerations

Practical Tax Considerations

In our experience, companies should consider these practical tax aspects when deciding between models:

1. Revenue Threshold: At lower revenue levels, the administrative cost of subsidiary tax compliance often outweighs potential tax planning benefits
2. Business Lifecycle Stage: Early-stage companies typically benefit from the EOR's tax administration, while mature operations may justify the investment in subsidiary tax planning
3. Industry-Specific Factors: Certain industries have unique tax incentives in India that may only be accessible through a subsidiary structure
4. Repatriation Strategy: How you plan to move profits from India to your home country can significantly impact the tax efficiency of each model
5. Future Exit Plans: Tax implications of eventual market exit differ substantially between models

Q6: How Does the Exit Process Differ Between EOR and Subsidiary Models in India? [toc=Exit Process]

Based on our experience helping companies both enter and exit the Indian market, we've observed significant differences in the complexity, timeline, and costs associated with winding down operations under each model. Understanding these differences is crucial for companies considering their market entry strategy, as exit planning should be part of your initial decision-making process.

Exiting Through an EOR Model

Timeline and Process

• Remarkably quick exit process - as fast as "under 5 minutes" for the formal disengagement
• Simple contract termination with your EOR provider
• No formal shutdown procedures with government authorities
• No mandatory notice periods beyond what's in your service agreement

Employee Transition Process

• Clear communication to employees about the termination of contracts
• Severance and notice periods managed by the EOR
• EOR handles all final tax calculations and settlements
• Full legal compliance with termination requirements

Financial Implications

• Minimal exit costs beyond contractually obligated employee severance
• No winding-up fees or long-term financial commitments
• No asset liquidation complexities
• Quick financial disentanglement from the Indian market

Documentation Requirements

• Simple termination notice to the EOR provider
• Confirmation of final payments and settlements
• Limited record-keeping requirements post-exit

Exiting a Subsidiary in India

Timeline and Process

• Extensive and time-consuming process typically taking 3-4.5 years
• Multiple regulatory approvals required
• Formal application for striking off or winding up
• Mandatory notice periods and public announcements
• Final tax clearances from multiple authorities

Key Statutory Requirements

1. Board resolution approving company closure
2. Settling all outstanding liabilities and creditor claims
3. Employee termination following proper legal procedures
4. Tax clearance certificates from income tax and GST authorities
5. No objection certificates from relevant regulatory bodies
6. Submission of application to Registrar of Companies
7. Final distribution of assets to shareholders

Financial Implications

• Significant professional fees for legal and accounting services
• Ongoing compliance costs during the wind-down period
• Asset liquidation considerations
• Potential tax implications on capital gains
• Reserve Bank of India approvals for repatriation of funds

Common Challenges

• Outstanding legal disputes delaying the process
• Tax assessments remaining open for several years
• Regulatory complexities in specific sectors
• Employee litigation risks
• Difficulty in obtaining all necessary clearances

Comparative Analysis of Exit Processes

Q7: Can Companies Transition from a Subsidiary to an EOR Model in India? [toc=Transition Process]

Based on our extensive experience working with multinational companies in India, we can confirm that transitioning from a subsidiary to an EOR model is not only possible but becoming increasingly common as companies reassess their operational strategies in the Indian market. This transition can offer significant advantages for companies looking to simplify their operations while maintaining their presence in India.

When to Consider Transitioning from Subsidiary to EOR

Companies typically consider this transition when:

• The compliance burden and administrative costs of maintaining a subsidiary outweigh the benefits
• Business operations have evolved and no longer require a full legal entity
• The company needs to reduce operational expenses while retaining key talent
• Market strategy has shifted from direct sales to support or development functions
• The company is reassessing its global footprint but wants to retain its Indian team

Benefits of Transitioning to an EOR Model

When you switch from a subsidiary to an EOR, companies typically experience:

• Reduced Compliance Burden: Once the transition is complete, you're no longer responsible for complex subsidiary-related compliance requirements1
• Cost Savings: Elimination of entity maintenance costs, compliance expenses, and administrative overhead
• Operational Simplification: Administrative responsibilities shift to the EOR while you maintain operational control
• Retained Local Presence: You continue to maintain your workforce and business capabilities in India
• Focus on Core Business: Resources previously dedicated to administrative tasks can be redirected to strategic activities

Practical Considerations

During this transition, companies should be mindful of several important factors:

1. Employee Communication: Clear, transparent communication with employees is essential to maintain morale and retention during the transition
2. Timing and Planning: The transition should be carefully planned to minimize disruption to business operations
3. Legal and Tax Implications: Consult with legal and tax advisors to understand all implications of the transition
4. Intellectual Property Management: Ensure proper transfer or protection of intellectual property during the transition
5. Client/Customer Relationships: Manage any potential impact on client relationships during the structural change

Q8: How Can Wisemonk Help with Your EOR Needs in India? [toc=Why Wisemonk]

As a specialized Employer of Record service provider focused exclusively on the Indian market, Wisemonk offers comprehensive solutions for companies looking to hire and manage employees in India without establishing a legal entity. Our deep understanding of local laws, regulations, and business practices positions us as an ideal partner for companies at any stage of their India journey.

Why Choose Wisemonk as Your EOR Partner in India

India-Exclusive Focus
Unlike global EOR providers that operate across multiple countries, Wisemonk specializes exclusively in the Indian market, offering:

• Deep expertise in Indian labor laws and compliance requirements
• Nuanced understanding of local business practices and cultural considerations
• Specialized knowledge of India's complex regulatory environment

Comprehensive End-to-End Services
We provide a holistic range of services that extend beyond traditional EOR offerings:

• Talent Acquisition: We leverage our extensive network to help you identify and recruit top talent in India
• EOR Services: From onboarding to contract management, we handle all employer responsibilities seamlessly
• Payroll Management: We ensure accurate and timely payroll processing, including tax deductions and compliance reporting
• Tax Optimization: Drawing on our deep knowledge of Indian tax laws, we help structure operations for maximum tax efficiency
• Office Setup Support: Whether you need a small office or large-scale operation, we assist with establishing your physical presence
• Global Capability Center (GCC) Expertise: We specialize in helping businesses build dedicated offshore teams in India

Client Testimonials

As noted by Dan Sampson, Head of Engineering at Cobu, "Wisemonk has been a pure pleasure to work with." This focus on client satisfaction has made us a preferred choice for businesses seeking reliable and efficient EOR solutions in India.

By partnering with Wisemonk as your EOR in India, you gain not just a service provider but a strategic partner dedicated to your success in one of the world's most dynamic markets. Our comprehensive approach ensures you can focus on your core business while we handle the complexities of Indian employment and compliance.

‍

‍